Reservations
Most of our seating is available on a first come, first served basis so if you do not see a reservation available, don’t fret… we offer very limited reservations for parties of 6-10 people. There could still be seating available for walk-ins and we encourage you to visit the restaurant in person. Please send a member of your party to speak with the host and if there is a wait, we will notify your party when your table is ready.
Reservation Policy details:
We offer limited reservations for groups of 6-10 people.
We are currently booking reservations within 2 weeks of today’s date.
If there is a wait, it is managed daily by the host.
We kindly ask that all reservations limit their time to 2 hours
For larger party inquiries, please email info@eventideoysterco.com
Takeout and Delivery
All takeout orders will take approximately 15 to 30 minutes.
Order delivery from CarHop!
Please note: When you arrive to pick up a takeout order come to the host stand inside and a staff member will assist you. If you have purchased alcohol, you will need to have your ID ready for review.
Hours
Open 7 days a week
11am - 11pm
Eat & Drink
To Eat
our menu changes daily—this is a sample of typical offerings
RAW
Oysters on The Half Shell
FROM MAINE
Winter Point Selects
Norumbega
John's River
Basket Island
Pemaquid
Flying Point
North Haven
Glidden Point
Otter Cove
Dodge Cove
Wet Smack
Love Point
FROM AWAY
Beau Soleil
Irish Point
Shellfish
Littleneck Clams
Maine Crab Claws
Accoutrements
Cocktail Sauce
Red Wine Mignonette
Tabasco Ice
Kimchi Ice
Pickled Red Onion Ice
Horseradish Ice
COLD
Bluefin Tuna Crudo
Ginger-Scallion, Tare, Radish
Halibut Ceviche
Pique De Piña, Cilantro, Lime
Bluefin Tuna Tartare
Gochujang, Sesame, Turmeric Puff
Greens
Nori Vinaigrette, Pickled Vegetables
BUNS & ROLLS
Eventide Brown Butter Lobster Roll
Fried Oyster Bun
Tartar, Pickled Vegetables
House Pastrami Bun
Sauerkraut, Swiss, 1000 Island
Fried Chicken Bun
Gochujang, Apricot, Daikon
Maine Crab Bun
Yuzu Kosho Mayo, Lime
SIDES
Cole Slaw
Kimchi
Potato Chips
HOT
New England Clam Chowder
Potato, Salt Pork, Saltines
Maine Lobster Stew
Coconut, Green Curry, Maitake
Battered Casco Bay Pollock
House Tartar, Lemon
Fried Shishitos
Scallion Vinaigrette, Fried Garlic, Cilantro
Scallop Waffle-Yaki
Tempura, Kabayaki, Umami Mayo
Fried Chicken Sandwich
Maple Chinese Mustard, Lettuce, Pickles
The Fish Sandwich
Shredded Iceberg, Tartar, Pickles, Tare
Smoked Tofu Sandwich
Onion Rings, Iceberg Lettuce, Roasted Jalapeño Mayo
Eventide Burger
Tallow Mayo, Pickles, American Cheese
NEW ENGLAND CLAM BAKE
Dig in and get your hands dirty with this quintessential New England experience.
Steamers, mussels, lobster tail, potatoes, salt pork and a hard boiled egg nestled into a bed of rock seaweed. Served with drawn butter and nori vinaigrette. Enjoy.
SWEETS
Ice Cream Sandwich
Chocolate Chip Cookie, Vanilla Ice Cream
Whoopie Pie
Oatmeal Cream Pie
Chocolate Coconut Brownie
To Drink
Our beverage menu is always changing, but this is a reliable sample of what to expect. We offer a collection of fine spirits in addition to our renowned cocktail list. Wines are carefully chosen to compliment our menu offerings and vast selection of oysters. A special stash of large format bottles are perfect for a crowd at holidays and other special occasions. Draught beers change seasonally and are always local. We look forward to raising a glass - Cheers!
About
Eventide marks the transition between day and night, a time that calls for refreshment and rejuvenation. Eventide Oyster Co. offers a variety of restoratives—we welcome you to join us at any time of day for satisfying food, spirits and good cheer.
A revival of the great American oyster bar, Eventide Oyster Co. offers pristine shellfish and a fresh take on classic New England fare—such proximity to the Gulf of Maine provides the sharpest seafood money can buy. A wine list chosen to complement shellfish, craft cocktails, and a warm sense of hospitality bring laid-back extravagance to Portland’s Old Port.
Sunken into the concrete bar sits an enormous block of Maine granite that serves as the shellfish display, home to an ever-changing array of oysters and shellfish. The restaurant’s bright colors, picnic table seating and reclaimed nautical lighting encourage a playful experience.
Private Events
We can accommodate Large Groups · Private Parties · Special Events
Team
ANDREW TAYLOR
Owner & Chef
Andrew Taylor is bearded, has four cubs and lives with his wife just outside of Portland. He worked briefly as Rosie O’Donnell’s stunt double.
ARLIN SMITH
Owner & General Manager
Arlin Smith has a beard, a daughter, and a hiatal hernia. He crushes wings every chance he gets.
peter hunt
Bar & Assistant Manager
Zoe taylor
Wine Coordinator
laura cinquegrano
Assistant Manager
jared leaman-Farley
Chef de Cuisine
Taylor Robertson
Executive Sous Chef
Brendan Murray
Sous Chef
EMPLOYMENT
We are always interested in connecting with potential employees. Ideal candidates will demonstrate a genuine sense of hospitality, eagerness to learn, and a strong work ethic. Bring a resume and cover letter to 86 Middle Street or inquire at info@eventideoysterco.com.
Press
Sleek and spacious, with floor-to-ceiling windows and light blue walls — on approach, you’d swear you were entering the Apple store. Stools and counters overlook bustling Boylston Street; there are also a few longer tables and stools without views. Order from a series of flat screens at the entrance, beneath which a friendly server stands, device at the ready, to take orders. You’ll receive a text when your food is ready. Pick everything up at a rock-walled counter topped with oysters on ice, and then relax: There’s mellow guitar music on the speakers, and you’ll (almost) forget the bustle on the other side of the glass.
Two chefs from Maine received a James Beard Award – a coveted recognition that chefs consider to be the Oscars of the food world – on Monday night.
Mike Wiley and Andrew Taylor, chef/co-owners of three Portland restaurants, won the award in the Best Chef: Northeast category.
Along with their manager, Arlin Smith, Wiley and Taylor own and operate Eventide Oyster Co., The Honey Paw and Hugo’s. This was their third nomination. They were finalists last year.
When I visited Portland, ME for the first time this March, I was instantly charmed by the way the city seemed the perfect marriage of old school and new. On one hand, it was quintessentially New England with its stunning seascapes, cobblestone streets and everyone-knows-everyone warmth. On the other hand, the city’s rich cultural offerings, eco-friendliness and diverse community lent Portland a distinctly modern feel.
And the food.
Fore Street and The Honey Paw, both in Portland, are among the restaurants named, and five chefs from four restaurants are in the running for Best Chef: Northeast.
Nine Maine restaurants, chefs and brewmasters are among this year’s semifinalists for James Beard Awards, considered the most prestigious in the American food world.
Maine’s 2016 semifinalists cover seven categories – there are 21 restaurant and chef categories in all – including Best New Restaurant and Outstanding Restaurant. The group was selected from more than 20,000 online entries.
The Honey Paw in Portland is a semifinalist in the Best New Restaurant category, which is given to a restaurant opened in 2015 that “already displays excellence … and is likely to make a significant impact in years to come.”
The 2015 James Beard Awards, hosted by Alton Brown, will be held at Lyric Opera of Chicago on Monday, May 4. Carla Hall will host our Book, Broadcast, and Journalism Awards Dinner, taking place at New York City's Pier Sixty at Chelsea Piers on Friday, April 24. Tickets to the main gala go on sale April 1, while BBJ ceremony tickets are now available online.
Announcing the Nominees for the 2015 James Beard Foundation Awards, Presented by Lexus
Best Chef: Northeast
Karen Akunowicz, Myers + Chang, Boston
Barry Maiden, Hungry Mother, Cambridge, MA
Masa Miyake, Miyake, Portland, ME
Cassie Piuma, Sarma, Somerville, MA
Andrew Taylor and Mike Wiley, Eventide Oyster Co., Portland, ME
Bill Addison
Lobster will always be Maine's king crustacean, but this nonstop-crowded bar in Portland specializes in the state's other seafood star. The menu divides the oysters, displayed over ice on a counter cut from rugged granite, into categories using local parlance: "From Maine" and "From Away." Start by slurping local gems like citrusy Pemaquids from the Damariscotta River. Accoutrements go traditional (cocktail sauce, mignonette) and inventive (ices flavored with blasts of cucumber and ginger or kimchi).
F&W Editors
New England Region Winners Andrew Taylor and Mike Wiley:
Why they're amazing: Their restaurant combines the best of old-school Maine oyster bars with updates like cleverly flavored sauces (kimchi ice) and fried oysters served in steam buns, Korean style.
Culinary School: Both are self-taught.
Background: Taylor - Daniel's Broiler, Rover's (Seattle), Clio (Boston), Hugo's (Portland, ME). Wiley - Elk Creek Lodge (Meeker, CO), Black Cat (Boulder, CO), Hugo's (Portland, ME)...
Doug Merriam
In a state where lobster is king, Eventide’s dedication to the mighty oyster is a bold move. The menu lists around 20 different varieties displayed in a massive trough of Maine granite on the bar. All are pristine and offered raw with creative “accouterment” like kim chee ice or a mimosa mignonette (yes, you can still get cocktail sauce). There is lobster here too, only Eventide’s take on a lobster roll comes in a Chinese bun and is offered with not just mayo, but a brown butter vinaigrette or hollandaise.
Meredith Goad
Slurp down a half dozen oysters on the half shell and chances are you'll be washing them down with a beer. But how many people have tried oysters in their beer? You'll soon get your chance, becasue Arlin Smith of Eventide Oyster Co. and Chresten Sorensen of Bunker Brewing Co. have been collaborating on an oyster stout using Maine Winter Point oysters...
F&W Staff with Eric Steinman
This restaurant in the Old Port district specializes in Maine oysters, including Winter Point Selects, a variety raised by the renowned harvester John Hennessey, in West Bath. “The Winter Points are about an inch and a half in size and have a very clean, bright and briny taste,” says Eventide co-owner Arlin Smith. “A smaller oyster is special because it has amazing salinity.” Hennessey also provides the restaurant with big, meaty seven- to 10-year-old oysters, which chefs Andrew Taylor and Mike Wiley roast in a thick, Korean-style barbecue sauce. The caramelized oysters are served in their shells, topped with coleslaw, crispy fried potato strings and a drizzle of chile oil
Meredith Goad
Food & Wine magazine runs the annual contest, which allows the public to vote for one of 100 outstanding chefs from 10 different regions. Chefs Andrew Taylor and Mike Wiley of Eventide Oyster Co. in Portland are in the running for the title "The People's Best New Chef". The nominees are allowed to campaign for votes, and the Eventide group is taking the challenge seriously - kind of. They produced a humorous, professionally done video for their website, with a link that goes to the contest's voting page.
Photo: Zack Bowen, Knack Factory
Photo: Douglas Merriam, Douglas Merriam Food
Photo: Zack Bowen, Knack Factory
Photo: Douglas Merriam, Douglas Merriam Food
Photo: Zack Bowen, Knack Factory
Photo: Douglas Merriam, Douglas Merriam Food
Photo: Zack Bowen, Knack Factory
Photo: Douglas Merriam, Douglas Merriam Food
Photo: Zack Bowen, Knack Factory